The Ridiculousness of the NCAA: I just want to take a moment to note that the NCAA once again has prove why it is the target of ridicule, reform, and possibly even revolt by its large member institutions. I have discussed this subject endlessly, but two recent decisions have proven once again how troubled this institution has become.



First, there was the decision not to let Jeremy Bloom participate in college football this year because he has endorsement deals that allow him to train to be an Olympic skier. As I have noted here, there is no reason why Bloom should not be able to accept endorsements that clearly have no relation to his playing college football. The decision means one of two things. One, it could mean that the NCAA is not willing to make decisions on an individual basis, despite assertions to the contrary. Or it could mean that the organization is punishing Bloom for causing such a ruckus, including his filing of a lawsuit. The message: don't mess with us.



The second rationale seems especially appropriate in the case of Mike Williams. In August, the NCAA rejected his application for reinstatement, despite the fact that he had returned all of the money he had taken, severed all ties with his agent and attended summer school. His penalty: he followed the law. For a time last spring, a federal district court ruled that the NFL had to admit him to its draft. Following this ruling, Williams declared for the draft. However, when the 2nd Circuit overturned the decision, Williams (and Maurice Clarett) were left out.



Williams attempted to become a professional. He sought to leave the NCAA and seek a new football life. He was caught in a unique legal situation that was not his doing and certainly not his fault. While he did break some NCAA rules in the process, the association should have realized the uniqueness of the situation and made an exception. But, it sought to make an example: if you try and turn professional early, the NCAA scorns you. You will not be welcome back.



So, Mike Williams and Jeremy Bloom sit on the sidelines. But if schools become disillusioned with such tyrannical practices, ultimately it may be the NCAA that is the biggest loser.

Posted in: